Tympanoplasty

Tympanoplasty is a surgical procedure performed to eradicate infection and restore the function of the middle ear.¹ Wullstein^2,³ introduced a classification for tympanoplasty that is based on two things: (1) the remaining structures of the middle ear after all pathology has been eradicated, and (2) how sound is transferred to the oval window while the round window is being protected. The basic principles behind this classification still hold true today, but the practice of tympanoplasty has been modified by advances in the fields of optics, microsurgical instruments, middle ear prostheses, and surgical techniques. The presence of different tympanoplasty techniques is an indication that the otologic surgeon should be flexible when tailoring the procedure to fit the disease, rather than having a “one-size-fits-all” approach to surgery for chronic ear disease. This chapter reviews various tympanoplasty techniques and techniques for reconstructing the ossicular chain. Tympanoplasty is often performed in conjunction with mastoidectomy in cases of active chronic suppurative otitis media. Mastoidectomy techniques are reviewed in Chapters 127 and 142.

Functional Considerations

Restoration of the middle ear transformer mechanism requires a secure connection between an intact tympanic membrane and inner ear fluids. The tympanic membrane should close an air-filled, mucosa-lined middle ear cavity. Traditional teaching attributes most of the middle ear gain to the hydraulic effect, which is the ratio of the effective vibrating area of the tympanic membrane to the area of the mobile stapes footplate.⁴ Round window protection to avoid phase cancellation (i.e., when sound impacts the oval and round windows at the same time) was also thought to be an important contributor to effective sound transmission to the inner ear. More recent investigations of human middle ear mechanisms modified these classic teachings in the following ways⁵:

1. Sound can be transmitted from the ear canal to the cochlea by two mechanisms: ossicular and acoustic coupling. Ossicular coupling is the sound pressure gain that occurs through the tympanic membrane and the ossicular chain. Acoustic coupling is the difference in the sound pressure that is acting directly on the oval and round windows. In normal ears, acoustic coupling is negligible, but it may play a significant role in diseased and reconstructed ears.

2. When sound input to the cochlea depends solely on acoustic coupling (e.g., ossicular interruption behind an intact tympanic membrane, complete absence of the tympanic membrane and ossicles), the stimulus to the cochlea depends on the relative magnitude and the phase (timing difference) of the oval and round window pressures. The magnitude difference is more important than the phase difference.

3. The pressure gain that results from ossicular coupling in normal ears is frequency-dependent, and its magnitude is less than traditionally believed. The mean middle ear gain is about 20 dB between 250 and 500 Hz, reaches a maximum of about 25 dB around 1 kHz, and then decreases at about 6 dB per octave at frequencies greater than 1 kHz.

4. There is also a contribution of the stapes-cochlear impedance and the round window membrane to middle ear function. Normally, motion of the stapes footplate is “opposed” by the annular ligament, the cochlear fluids and partition, and the round window membrane. Pathologic changes in the impedance of the annular ligament, the cochlea, or the round window can cause hearing loss, such as that caused by otosclerotic stapes fixation. Also, in a nonaerated middle ear, the presence of fluid or fibrous tissue within the round window niche can increase the round window impedance and cause conductive loss.

5. Aeration of the middle ear plays an important role in sound transmission. In addition to contributing to normal stapes-cochlear impedance (see previously), aeration is crucial for normal ossicular coupling. The compressible air within the middle ear allows the tympanic membrane and the ossicles to move.^6,⁷ Impaired middle ear aeration can adversely affect ossicular coupling by altering a pressure difference that is important to middle ear function. In the normal human middle ear, sound pressure in the ear canal is higher than sound pressure within the middle ear; tympanic membrane motion is driven by this pressure difference. Reductions in middle ear air volume that result from disease or surgery lead to elevated middle ear airspace impedance and an increase in middle ear sound pressure. This leads to a reduction in the pressure difference across the tympanic membrane, with a subsequent reduction in tympanic membrane and ossicular motion.⁵ The minimum amount of air required to maintain ossicular coupling within 10 dB of normal has been estimated to be 0.5 mL.⁸

A perforation of the tympanic membrane causes hearing loss by reducing the difference in sound pressure across the two sides of the tympanic membrane, causing decreased ossicular coupling.⁹ Hearing loss is proportional to the size of perforation and is frequency dependent, with the largest losses occurring at the lowest sound frequencies.¹⁰ It also varies inversely with volume of the middle ear airspace (including the mastoid); this may explain why seemingly identical perforations in size and location produce different degrees of hearing loss, and why hearing loss may fluctuate in a given perforation with the presence or absence of otorrhea, which would decrease middle ear and mastoid airspace, causing increased hearing loss. More recent investigations also suggest that hearing loss does not vary appreciably with the location of perforation, in contrast to the long-held belief that posteroinferior perforations result in greater hearing loss than perforations at other locations owing to increased phase cancellation at the round window.^10,¹¹

Preoperative Evaluation

A detailed history and careful physical examination are essential to the planning of the surgical approach and the counseling of patients regarding the expected outcome. The extent of tympanic membrane perforation and the condition of the ossicular chain are evaluated. The health of the remaining membrane is assessed, paying particular attention to atrophic areas and the degree of myringosclerosis. The size of the external canal is evaluated, and canalplasty is planned if a prominent anterior canal wall prevents complete visualization of the perforation. Comprehensive audiometric evaluation is performed, and tuning fork tests are used to confirm the audiogram. Radiographic evaluation is usually not needed if clinical examination reveals a dry central perforation.

As mentioned previously, postoperative aeration of the middle ear is key to the success of tympanic membrane repair and the restoration of hearing. The otologic surgeon has no direct control over this factor, however, which depends mostly on eustachian tube function. There is currently no test that accurately predicts postoperative eustachian tube function. Some indicators—the aeration of the opposite ear, increased age in children, fewer episodes of otorrhea, and normal middle ear mucosa—may suggest reasonable eustachian tube function. In many cases, however, surgery is the ultimate test, and may result in improved eustachian tube function by preventing recurrent infections through contamination from the external auditory canal.

This chapter deals mainly with techniques for repair of dry tympanic membrane perforations. Techniques for handling active chronic otitis media with or without cholesteatoma are described in other chapters. In brief, it is recommended that the ear be dry for 3 to 4 weeks before proceeding with tympanoplasty. There are situations, however, in which the ear cannot be successfully treated medically, and tympanoplasty with or without mastoidectomy may be the best therapeutic option.

Graft Materials

Temporalis fascia is the most commonly used material for the repair of tympanic membrane perforations; it was introduced for this use in the early 1960s.¹² Temporalis fascia can be harvested at the time of tympanoplasty through a small incision posterosuperior to the helix in the hair-bearing scalp when using a transcanal approach, or via superior dissection from a postauricular or endaural incision. Other grafting materials have also been used.¹³^–¹⁵ In 1960, Shea¹⁵ described the use of vein grafts in tympanoplasty. Perichondrium is frequently used in tympanoplasty, particularly if there is no temporalis fascia available (e.g., in cases of multiple revisions) or if a composite cartilage/perichondrium graft is needed to prevent retraction of the reconstructed membrane when there is suspected persistent eustachian tube dysfunction. The periosteum on the medial surface of the temporalis muscle can also be used as a graft material when temporalis fascia is unavailable if the surgeon wishes to avoid the additional incision needed to harvest tragal perichondrium.

Ringenberg ¹⁴ used free autologous fat grafts in the early 1960s. A more recent study reported success rates with fat grafts to be comparable to success rates with temporalis fascia.¹⁶ AlloDerm (LifeCell Corporation, Branchburg, NJ) has also been studied and used as a graft material.¹⁷^–²⁰ To support the use of AlloDerm as a possible alternative to autologous fascia, advocates cite the avoidance of external incisions, potential reduction of surgical time, and comparable success rates.²⁰

Minimalist Techniques

There are some clinical situations in which a minimalist approach to tympanoplasty is possible or desirable. Small, uninfected, established perforations of 1- to 2-mm diameter can often be managed in an office setting in this way. The epithelium at the margins of the perforation is cauterized or removed, and a fat plug that is slightly larger than the diameter of the perforation is removed from the lobule to use as a graft. It is placed through the opening in a dumbbell fashion and covered with a dressing such as Gelfoam or Gelfilm (Pharmacia & Upjohn Company, Kalamazoo, MI, a division of Pfizer Inc., New York, NY). Other surgeons prefer simply to cauterize the perforation edges with trichloroacetic acid or phenol and apply a patch of Gelfoam, Gelfilm, cigarette paper, or a hyaluronic acid film (Epidisc; Medtronic Xomed Inc., Jacksonville, FL). Traumatic perforations also are often managed by patching only after the perforation edges are realigned. In addition, a more recent study described the use of a simple device in the shape of a sealed tympanostomy tube (Medtronic Xomed Inc., Jacksonville, FL) that is designed to be inserted into tympanic membrane perforations in patients when surgery is contraindicated or refused by the patient.²¹

Formal Tympanoplasty (see Key Indicator Video on website)

Anesthesia

Tympanoplasty can be performed under local or general anesthesia. In children and anxious adults, general anesthesia is preferred. In either case, the ear canal skin is injected with lidocaine (usually 1%) with epinephrine (1 : 100,000) for vasoconstriction. Care should be taken to avoid the formation of fluid blebs in the skin, which can occur if excessive force is used to inject, especially if a larger syringe is used. Injection should be done using a microscope, preferably before preparing the ear so that there is time allowed for vasoconstriction to occur. If liquid povidone-iodine (Betadine) is used to prepare the ear, its entry into the middle ear should be avoided.

Approaches and Incisions

Three main approaches are used in tympanoplasty: transcanal, endaural, and postauricular. The approach used depends on the perforation size, the anatomy of the external auditory canal, and the surgeon’s preference. Most importantly, the approach used should provide complete visualization of the perforation. The transcanal approach is usually employed for small posterior perforations or for medium-sized perforations when the ear canal anatomy is favorable, and the entire perforation and an anterior tympanic membrane rim can be seen; it should be avoided in cases in which the anterior margin of the perforation is not well visualized, particularly in the hands of surgeons with less experience. The endaural approach can be used with all perforations and is more commonly used in Europe; it is most useful if a limited atticotomy is anticipated in conjunction with tympanoplasty. A self-retaining retractor can be used with this approach. The postauricular approach is the most commonly used approach for tympanoplasty in the United States. It can be used with all perforation sizes, and offers a better angle of visualization of the anterior tympanic membrane, even without canalplasty. The use of self-retaining retractors allows for easier use of both hands for instrumentation and suctioning.

Transcanal incisions outline a medially based tympanomeatal flap. Superior and inferior incisions start at 12 o’clock and 6 o’clock. Either the incisions converge to meet on the posterior canal wall, forming a triangular skin flap (Fig. 141-1A), or each incision may be extended laterally for 6 to 7 mm, at which point the lateral ends of the incisions are connected by a horizontal incision that forms a rectangular flap (Fig. 141-1B). Before the elevation of the flap, the edge of the perforation is excised. A sharp straight pick is used to create small holes around the periphery of the perforation, similar to those of a postage stamp (see Fig. 141-1A); this outlined edge can be removed with a cupped forceps.

Figure 141-1. A, Triangular tympanomeatal flap; perforation edge is prepared for excision by creating small holes along the perimeter. B, Rectangular tympanomeatal flap.

The excision of the perforation edge to disrupt the epithelial union is an integral part of any tympanoplasty procedure, whatever the approach, incision, or technique used. Any large areas of tympanosclerosis should be removed. The outlined skin flap is elevated medially usually using a round knife. Care is taken to minimize suctioning on the flap. Suctioning should be done between the instrument used to elevate the flap and the bony canal. Elevation should be performed along the entire breadth of the flap rather than by the creation of a tunnel in the middle. After the anulus is reached, it is elevated from the tympanic sulcus, exposing the middle ear mucosa, which is divided to enter the middle ear. Elevation of the anulus from the sulcus is continued superiorly and inferiorly under direct vision; this minimizes the risk of injury to a dehiscent, high-riding jugular bulb. Care should be taken to avoid injury of the chorda tympani with superior elevation of the flap. When elevation has reached the limits of the incision, it is usually possible to tuck the tympanomeatal flap anteriorly, where it is not interfering with the surgical field.

The endaural incision has a vertical limb that usually starts at 12 o’clock at the bony cartilaginous junction and extends laterally and superiorly into the cartilage-free incisura terminalis between the superior aspect of the tragus and the root of the helix (Fig. 141-2A). The incision is deepened to expose the inferior edge of the temporalis muscle, where a fascial graft can be taken. The vertical limb can be combined with one of the medially based tympanomeatal flaps described previously, an inferiorly based skin flap (Fig. 141-2B), or a laterally based Koerner flap extending onto the concha (Fig. 141-2C) (allowing cartilage excision and meatoplasty), depending on the planned surgery.

Figure 141-2. A, Hatched line shows the vertical limb of the endaural incision starting at the bony cartilaginous junction and extending laterally and superiorly into the cartilage-free incisura terminalis, between the superior aspect of the tragus and the root of the helix. B and C, The vertical limb can be combined with an inferiorly based skin flap (B), or a laterally based Koerner flap extending onto the concha (C).

The postauricular incision usually extends from the mastoid tip to just above the attachment of the helix, about 5 to 6 mm from the postauricular crease. The incision is deepened in layers, with care taken not to injure the periosteum. Care is also taken not to elevate the auricle as a separate layer from the periosteum because this can lead to a lop-ear deformity postoperatively. The temporalis muscle and fascia are exposed. The periosteum is incised in a “7” or “T” fashion. The presence of this acute angle allows for the precise repositioning of the periosteum during closure, avoiding any misalignment of the auricle or any change of its vertical position postoperatively. The periosteum is elevated forward, exposing the spine of Henle and the ear canal.

There are several options for handling the posterior canal wall skin. The canal skin can be elevated from behind with care taken not to tear the skin, particularly at its attachment at the tympanomastoid and tympanosquamous suture lines. If there is a very prominent tympanosquamous suture line, it is often helpful to incise the fibrous tissue within the suture line using a sickle knife or a 59-10 Beaver blade. The skin is elevated down to the anulus, which should be left intact at this time; vascular strip incisions can be made from behind to access the ear canal. Vertical incisions placed at the 6 o’clock and 12 o’clock positions are connected by a horizontal incision just lateral to the anulus to create a long vascular strip. The other option is to perform the vascular strip incisions through the ear canal before starting the postauricular incision.²² In cases in which there is no perforation, and surgery is performed for a second look or for ossiculoplasty (especially if an incus interposition is contemplated), it is possible not to do any canal incisions, and instead to elevate the canal skin and anulus in continuity, entering the middle ear for inspection and ossicular reconstruction.

Graft Placement

Medial and lateral techniques refer to the placement of the graft either medial or lateral to the tympanic membrane remnant. Although some surgeons advocate a certain technique for graft placement in a particular situation, the success of any technique depends on how well this technique is performed by the surgeon, rather than on the technique itself. Consequently, there should not be an absolute indication for a particular technique in a certain perforation. Medial technique can be used to repair total perforations or in revision cases if done properly by an experienced surgeon.

Lateral Graft Technique

In lateral technique tympanoplasty, which is also known as the overlay technique, the graft is placed lateral to the fibrous layer of the tympanic membrane remnant, but medial to the malleus handle. This technique requires complete removal of the squamous epithelium from the lateral surface of the tympanic membrane remnant to avoid iatrogenic cholesteatoma formation. During elevation of the tympanomeatal flap, the anulus is left in the tympanic sulcus, and the dissection is transitioned from the bony external canal onto the lateral surface of the tympanic membrane, separating the superficial squamous layer from the middle fibrous layer. If the perforation is of medium size, the dissected epithelium can be left attached anteriorly and can be replaced on top of the graft. In total perforations, it is usually necessary to remove the skin of the external canal completely to ensure complete removal of squamous epithelium.

Canalplasty can be performed to remove the prominent anterior canal wall to visualize the entire perforation without having to move the microscope.²³ This is accomplished by connecting the lateral ends of the vascular strip incisions along the anterior canal wall just medial to the bony-cartilaginous junction (Fig. 141-3A). The skin is dissected medially toward the anulus (Fig. 141-3B). When the elevation reaches the area medial to the anterior canal bulge, the dissection is usually done by feel until the anulus is reached. The elevation of the epithelium from the tympanic membrane remnant is performed by developing a plane superiorly or inferiorly at the level of one of the original canal incisions, near the anulus. The squamous epithelium of the tympanic membrane remnant is usually left in continuity with the previously elevated canal skin. The anterior canal skin is trimmed of irregular tags and stored in a moist sponge.

Figure 141-3. A, Vascular strip incisions on posterior canal wall; the lateral ends of the vertical incisions are connected along the anterior canal wall just medial to the bony-cartilaginous junction. B, The canal skin is dissected medially toward the anulus. C, Visualization of the anterior sulcus may require removal of a significant amount of the anterior canal bone; bone is first removed in the superior and inferior corners of the anterior bony canal. D, The bony bulge is gradually taken down between the two corners. E, Placement of the graft (thick black line), with its anterior edge at the anulus supported by Gelfoam in the middle ear; the medial end of the replaced anterior canal skin (gray) should cover only 1 to 2 mm of the anterior end of the graft. F, Anterior blunting (gray); this is the result if the graft is placed on the anterior canal wall, or if the anterior canal skin covers a large area of the graft without maintaining the acute anterior tympanomeatal angle.

To ensure optimal graft placement, the anterior sulcus should be well visualized. This may require removal of a significant amount of the anterior canal bone (Fig. 141-3C). This removal is accomplished by using an otologic drill first to remove bone in the superior and inferior corners of the anterior bony canal. The bony bulge is gradually taken down between the two corners, keeping in mind that the prominent middle portion represents the posterior wall of the temporomandibular joint (Fig. 141-3D). It is of paramount importance to avoid violating the temporomandibular joint because this can lead to erosion of the condyle into the ear canal, which is extremely difficult to correct. In cases in which there is no anterior tympanic membrane remnant, placement of the graft may be facilitated by drilling a small trough just lateral to the anulus to create additional support for the graft anteriorly. Another alternative is to elevate the anulus from the sulcus anteriorly in continuity with the mucosa of the lateral wall of the eustachian tube, which provides a pocket to support the anterior portion of the graft.

If there is enough tympanic membrane remnant to support the graft, Gelfoam may be unnecessary in the middle ear. In large perforations, Gelfoam is placed in the middle ear to support the graft. The graft is trimmed to the proper size. The graft should be wide enough to cover the entire tympanic membrane region and long enough to drape onto the posterior canal wall. In placing the graft, care should be taken not to overlap any portion of the anterior canal wall, or blunting may occur (see later). Although the graft is placed lateral to the anulus, it should be placed medial to the malleus handle to prevent lateralization. This is usually accomplished by cutting a vertical slit in the anterosuperior corner of the graft to accommodate the malleus handle. If a significant tympanic membrane remnant is still attached to the malleus, incisions should be made sharply on either side of the malleus handle to allow for medial placement of the graft.

The trimmed anterior canal skin is repositioned with its thin medial part overlying approximately 1 mm of the graft (Fig. 141-3E). The anterior tympanomeatal angle should be maintained at an acute angle (≤90 degrees) by placing pressed, rolled, dry Gelfoam in the sulcus during healing. If the graft is placed on the anterior canal wall, or the acute anterior tympanomeatal angle is not preserved, a dead space is created that gets filled with fibrous tissue, resulting in blunting (Fig. 141-3F). This reduces the area of the vibratory portion of the tympanic membrane and causes persistent conductive hearing loss. Additional Gelfoam is placed over the graft except for the portion of the fascia that extends onto the posterior canal wall. The vascular strip skin is placed back, with care taken to unfurl the skin edges to avoid burying epithelium. Ideally, the vascular strip should be long enough to overlie a portion of the graft that is resting on the posterior canal wall. The periosteum is closed, with care taken not to lift the ear forward to avoid displacement of the vascular strip. After several sutures are placed in the periosteum, the vascular strip position is reinspected through a speculum, and the ear canal is filled with Gelfoam or antibiotic ointment. The postauricular wound is closed.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue