The Role of Molecular Genetics in the Assessment of Children with Congenital Cataract

 

Abnormality

Description

Structures involved

Pathogenesis

Associated gene

Transparency

Cataract

Opacity of the lens

Lens only

Protein misfolding, denaturation and/or loss of solubility

Numerous – see [12]

Peter’s Anomaly

Incomplete separation of the cornea and the lens

Lens and cornea

Failed separation of the LV from the SE

PAX6, FOXC1, PITX2, CYP1B1, FOXE3, PAX6, MAF

Shape

Lenticonus

Conical projection of either the anterior or posterior lens surface and may cause localised cataract

Lens only

Possibly a secondary defect to a thin lens capsule. Often associated with PHPV

COL4A3, COL4A5, COL4A5, TDRD7

Lentiglobus

Anterior or posterior bulging of the lens that is more spherical in shape than lenticonus

Coloboma

Scalloped edge or indentation of the lens. Lens opacities can frequently be found in the same region

Failure in zonular development

Numerous – see [13]

Position

Ectopia lentis

Dislocation of the lens

Lens and zonular fibres

Due to defects in the microfibrils of the ciliary zonule- usually asymmetrical excess of laxity or breakage of zonular fibres

ADAMTSL4, ADAMTS10, FBN1, LTBP2

Subluxation

Partial dislocation

Phacodonesis

Vibration of the lens upon eye/head movement

ADAMTS17, LTBP2

Size

Microphakia

Small lens

Lens only

Abnormal degree of contact between OV and SE during lens development

HMX1, LMXB1, RAB3GAP1

Microspherophakia

Small, spherical lens

As above and impeded/arrested secondary fibre development

LTBP2, ADAMTS17

Congenital aphakia

Absence of lens

Unsuccessful induction of the embryonic surface ectoderm in forming the lens placode and vesicle

FOXE3

Development

ASD

Developmental abnormality of anterior structures

Structures within the anterior segment

ASD due to defective lens development usually occurs as a result of failed molecular signalling and/or structural support from the lens for development of other components of the anterior segment. Frequently results in cataract plus microphakia, microcornea, and/or microphthalmia

FOXE3, PXDN, HMX1, PITX3, PAX6, OTX2, SIX6, VSX2, LTBP2, miR184, MAF, GJA8, CRYGD, CRYGC, CRYAA, CRYBB3, CRYBB2, CRYBB1, CRYBA4

(See also [13])


LV lens vesicle, SE surface ectoderm, PHPV persistent hypoplastic primary vitreous, OV optic vesicle, ASD anterior segment dysgenesis



A330328_1_En_3_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 3.1
Schematic diagram of the lens




3.2 How Is Lens Transparency Established and Maintained?


The lens has the highest protein concentration of any tissue within the human body, accounting for 38 % of its total wet weight [14]. Protein concentration is not uniform; higher concentrations exist in the lens nucleus creating a high refractive index (RI). A gradient of protein concentration, and corresponding RI, corrects for the ellipsoid shape of the lens and allows accurate light focussing across the entire structure. The cytoplasm of lens cells contains high concentrations (~0.2–0.4 g ml−1) of crystallin proteins. Lens crystallins are polydisperse and exist in a dense, short-range spatial order that does not alter with the increasing protein concentration range seen from the lens cortex, to the nucleus [14]. It is this specialized arrangement that allows crystallins to exist at high concentration whilst establishing a high level of transparency and protein stability, and to ensure the longevity of these proteins in the absence of cell turn-over, a vascular supply or innervation. There are two main families of crystallin proteins that exist in the human lens; the βγ-crystallin superfamily that function as structural proteins and the α-crystallins, which function both as structural proteins and as molecular chaperones. As chaperones, α-crystallins recognize and bind non-native and unfolded proteins to prevent accumulation as insoluble light scattering aggregates [15]. The beaded filament of the vertebrate lens is important for establishing the precise cellular architecture that is also critical for transparency. It has been suggested that the beaded filament may facilitate lens protein stability by providing a scaffold for, and thereby optimizing, protein chaperone function [16]. As a form of intermediate filament, the beaded filament may also support tissue integrity during the mechanical stresses of accommodation [17]. Within the human lens, the beaded filament assembles by the binding of BFSP1 (filensin) with BFSP2 (phakinin) [18].

The lens is a non-passive tissue. Since organelle degradation alters the physiology of lens fibre cells – to leave them incapable of generating energy and replacing damaged proteins – lens homeostasis is critical. Within the lens, a specialized internal microcirculatory system exists that delivers essential nutrients throughout the lens mass, whilst maintaining constant cellular volume and preserving tissue architecture. The vertebrate lens relies on the surrounding eye components to provide the nutrients it requires- the aqueous humor is fundamental in this, supplying the lens with metabolites such as glucose and amino acids at the anterior surface. It is also thought that the anterior lens epithelium is proactive in the take up of these molecules and ions for their subsequent diffusion in to the peripheral fibre cells [19]. The microcirculatory current travels through the lens via gap junctions comprised of connexin proteins that are present in the cell membranes of lens fibres. Gap junctions create an intracellular pathway, connecting cells at the surface of the lens mass with central cells. They are responsible for electrically coupling the anterior epithelial cells [20] and for the circulation of nutrients and ions throughout fibres of the lens mass, and the removal of metabolic waste products [21]. Water is circulated through membrane channels comprised of aquaporin 1 (AQP1) in lens epithelial cells [22], and major intrinsic protein (MIP) in fibre cells [23]. The breakdown of glucose by anaerobic metabolism is the main source of energy for both growth and homeostasis in the lens. Uptake of glucose from the aqueous humour appears to be mediated by the glucose transporter, GLUT1 in the lens epithelium, for circulation throughout the structure. Lens fibre cell membranes are incredibly cholesterol saturated such that bilayers form to create areas of pure cholesterol [24] that are thought to facilitate lens transparency by smoothing and maintaining the physical properties of cell membranes to prevent light scattering [25, 26]. The importance of cholesterol in the maintenance of lens clarity is apparent from genetic or therapeutic inhibition of cholesterol biosynthesis which leads to cataractogenesis [27].

Disruption of lens protein function can lead to cataract and other serious developmental abnormalities as highlighted in Table 3.2. A summary of the structural components of the lens and the features that establish and maintain its transparency can be found in Table 3.3.


Table 3.2
Details of lens proteins associated with non-syndromic congenital cataract, their function, respective disease mode of inheritance and phenotypes


















































































































































































































































Protein

Gene locus

Mode of inheritance

Function

Reported cataract morphologies

Additional phenotype(s)

FOXE3

1p32

AD/AR

Forkhead box-containing transcription factor involved in lens specification, the closure of the OV and its detachment from the SE

Cerulean

Microphthalmia, sclerocornea, microcornea, optic disc coloboma, dysplastic irides, Peter’s anomaly, glaucoma, aphakia

EPHA2

1p36.13

AD/AR

Ephrin receptor

Nuclear, cortical, posterior polar, zonular

Persistent foetal vasculature

GJA8

1q21.1

AD/AR

Gap junction protein for small molecule and ion transport

Nuclear, Total, Pulverulent, Y-sutural, Posterior subcapsular, diffuse, lamellar

Microcornea, glaucoma, myopia

CRYGD

2q33.3

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Punctate progressive, coralliform, nuclear, lamellar, cerulean, aceuleiform, anterior polar, posterior polar

Microcornea

PXDN

2p25.3

AR

Encodes peroxidasin and has a role in cell adhesion to the ECM
 
Microphthalmia, microcornea, sclerocornea, developmental glaucoma, ASD

CRYGC

2q33.3

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Zonular, pulverulent, nuclear, lamellar

Microphthalmia, microcornea, glaucoma, iris atrophy, corneal opacity, myopia

CRYGB

2q33.3

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Anterior polar, lamellar


CRYBA2

2q35

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Multifocal

Myopia, glaucoma, eccentric pupil

FYCO1

3p21.31

AR

Autophagosome trafficking

Nuclear


BFSP2

3q22.1

AD/AR

Combines with BFSP1 to form the beaded filament which establishes cellular architecture, provides a scaffold for protein chaperone function and supports tissue integrity during mechanical stress

Cortical, nuclear, Y-sutural, lamellar

Myopia

CRYGS

3q27.3

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Cortical progressive, sutural, lamellar, nuclear


VIM

10p13

AD

Intermediate filament protein that links the beaded filament to the plasma membrane of lens fibre cells

Pulverulent


PITX3

10q25

AD/AR

Homeobox-containing transcription factor that directly targets FOXE3; is involved in lens fibre cell proliferation and differentiation, and the regulation of crystallin expression

Progressive, posterior polar, posterior subcapsular

ASMD, microphthalmia, microcornia, sclerocornea, Perter’s anomaly

PAX6

11p13

AD

Paired-box-containing transcription factor and ‘master regulator of eye development’; involved in lens specification and development, optic fissure closure, and the regulation of crystallin gene expression
 
Aniridia, iris and foveal hypoplasia, corneal abnormalities, glaucoma

CRYAB

11q23.1

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein, molecular chaperone, cellular proteostasis (retina), cell death regulation, multispan transmembrane protein folding, cytoskeletal remodelling, and Z-disc support (skeletal muscle)

Nuclear, posterior polar, lamellar

Myofibrillar myopathy, cardiomyopathy

MIP

12q13

AD

Lens fiber membrane channel protein for water transport and forms adhesion complex in combination with LIM2.

Cerulean, lamellar, punctate, Y-sutural, total, posterior polar

Myopia

GJA3

13q12.11

AD

Gap junction protein for small molecule and ion transport

Nuclear, pulverulent, posterior polar, total, cortical, lamellar, coralliform, punctate


OTX2

14q22.3

AD

Homeobox-containing transcription factor involved in embryonic rostral patterning, brain development, lens specification, and rod cell differentiation in the retina
 
Microphthalmia and pattern dystrophy of the retina

SIX6

14q23.1

AR

Homeobox and SIX-domain-containing transcription factor involved in forebrain patterning, lens induction, and regulation of lens cell proliferation, specification and development
 
Microphthalmia

VSX2

14q24.3

AR

Homeobox-containing transcription factor involved in cell proliferation during eye development, and specification, development and maintenance of the neural retina.
 
Microphthalmia, anophthalmia, iris coloboma

LTBP2

14q24.3

AR

Exact role unknown but highly expressed in the trabecular meshwork and ciliary processes
 
Congenital glaucoma, microspherophakia, ectopia lentis

MiR184

15q25.1

AD

Involved in corneal lineage specification but role in the lens is unknown

Anterior polar

Endothelial dystrophy, stromal thinning, keratoconus, iris hypoplasia

HSF4

16q21

AD/AR

Heat-shock transcription factor: regulates fibroblast growth factor, γ-crystallin and beaded filament expression during lens growth and development

Cortical, total, lamellar, sutural, nuclear


MAF

16q23.2

AD

bZIP domain-containing transcription factor involved in lens fibre cell differentiation and regulation of crystallin expression

Nuclear, cerulean, lamellar, pulverulent, posterior polar

Peters anomaly, myopia, microcornea, iris coloboma

CRYBA1

17q11.2

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Nuclear, lamellar, pulverulent, Y-sutural, cortical


LIM2

19q13.4

AR

Combines with MIP to form robust adhesion complexes in mature lens fibre cells

Cortical, sutural


BFSP1

20p12.1

AD/AR

Combines with BFSP2 to form the beaded filament which establishes cellular architecture, provides a scaffold for protein chaperone function and supports tissue integrity during mechanical stress

Cortical progressive, nuclear


CRYAA

21q22.3

AD/AR

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein and molecular chaperone

Nuclear, lamellar, posterior polar, anterior polar, Y-sutural, disc-like membranous

Microcornea, iris coloboma, glaucoma, crneal opacity

CRYBB3

22q11.23

AD/AR

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Nuclear, cortical

Microcornea

CRYBB2

22q11.23

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein and function of the hippocampal network

Posterior subcapsular, cerulean, total, nuclear, disc-like membranous, lamellar, progressive polymorphic

Microcornea

CRYBB1

22q12.1

AD/AR

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Nuclear, pulverulent, progressive cortical

Glaucoma, microcornea

CRYBA4

22q12.1

AD

Structural cytoplasmic lens protein

Nuclear, lamellar

Microcornea, microphthalmia


RI refractive index, OFZ organelle free zone, MIP major intrinsic protein, LIM2 lens intrinsic membrane protein, AQP1 aquaporin 1



Table 3.3
Summary of the structural components of the lens and the factors that contribute to and maintain its transparency















































































   
Function

Key gene(s)/protein(s) and/or molecules

Structural Components

Fibre cells

Constitute >95 % of lens volume. Organisation facilitates transparency and tissue integrity

FGF, BMP, Wnt/PCP, TGF signalling

Crystallins, HSF3, PAX6, PITX3, PROX1, SOX1, SOX2 and C-MAF

Lens epithelium

Proliferation, differentiation and appendage of secondary fibre cells, uptake of nutrients from aqueous humour for homeostasis

Wnt/Notch signalling, E-cadherin, FOXE3, AP2α, PROX1, SOX1, C-MAF, YAP1

Lens capsule

Uptake of nutrients, ions, water from aqueous and vitreous humours, protects protein contents of the lens, and provides structural/mechanical support to the mass

Integrins, collagen IV, collagen XVIII, laminin, fibronectin, matrix metalloproteinases

Microplicae

Locks neighbouring fibre cells together to maintain structural integrity and prevent damage during lens accommodation

Cholesterol
     
Mechanism

Features for Transparency

Structural

Organelle degradation

Cellular organelles have a higher RI than the cytoplasm of lens cells, causing light scatter. Organelle degradation is synchronized upon terminal differentiation of lens fibre cells such that an OFZ is created at the centre of the lens, within the pupillary space

Tryptophan, DNase-IIβ, calpains

Protein concentration

Extremely high concentrations of crystallin proteins exist in dense, short-range spatial order within the cytoplasm of lens cells. Protein concentration is higher in the centre of the lens compared with the periphery, to correct for its ellipsoid shape

Crystallins

Beaded filament

Establishes cellular architecture and possibly provides a scaffold for protein chaperone function

BFSP1, BFSP2, α-crystallin, vimentin

Molecular chaperones

In the absence of protein turn-over, small heat-shock protein, α-crystallin, recognizes and binds non-native and/or unfolded proteins to prevent accumulation in to light scattering aggregates.

CRYAA and CRYAB (α-crystallin)

Structural & Homeostatic

Lipids & cholesterol

Lens fibre cell membranes are highly saturated with cholesterol and sphingolipids which are thought to smooth cell membranes, promote cell stability during accommodation, and maintain physical, physiological and homeostatic properties of lens fibres

Dihydrosphingomyelin, sphingolipids, cholesterol

Adhesive junctions

Adherens junction proteins are expressed in lens epithelial and fibre cell membranes and possibly maintain structural stability of fibres during lens development. MIP and LIM2 are also thought to form an adhesion complex that is unique to the lens that is important to organelle eliminated, mature fibre cells

N-cadherin, E-cadherin, MIP, LIM2

Lens capsule

Basement membrane surrounding the lens that helps shape the lens curvature during accommodation, promotes cell migration, differentiation and survival, protects the contents of the lens from the immune system, and is involved in the passive exchange of metabolic substrates and waste products in and out of the lens

(See above)

Homeostatic

Gap junctions

A network of intercellular channels for the transport of ions and small molecules throughout the lens mass for growth, development and maintenance of the lens and its contents

GJA8 (connexin 50), GJA3 (connexin 46), GJA1 (connexin 43)

Water channels

Membrane channels are integral for the circulation of water throughout the lens mass

AQP1, MIP

Anaerobic glycolysis

Uptake of glucose from the aqueous humour appears to be mediated by GLUT1, a glucose transporter that is highly expressed in the lens epithelium. The breakdown of glucose by anaerobic metabolism is the main source of energy for growth and maintenance of the lens

SLC2A1 (GLUT1), SLC2A3 (GLUT3)


3.3 What Constitutes the Formation of Cataracts in Children?


Lens opacities develop when the short-range order of crystallin protein is disturbed or the highly regular cellular organisation is disrupted, leading to fluctuation of protein density throughout the dimensions of the lens and resulting in regional differences in protein concentration [28]. At a molecular level, this may occur as a result of protein misfolding, instability or insolubility, leading to aggregation and altered interactions of proteins. Alterations in the homeostatic mechanisms or the physiological environment of the lens may indirectly impact upon crystallin proteins and also lead to cataractogenesis.

Aberrant protein folding results in the development of cataract when the accumulation of damage occurs at a faster rate than the lens chaperone α-crystallin, can manage, resulting in the formation of protein aggregates [28]. α-crystallin can identify partially or fully unfolded protein and segregate it, thus preventing its accumulative aggregation [29]. This mechanism is sufficient in the maintenance of lens clarity over an individual’s lifetime, where protein damage only accrues gradually with age. However, mutation of any one of the highly expressed lens crystallins will result in rapidly accumulating protein damage that is likely to overwhelm the chaperoning system [30]. Likewise, mutation of α-crystallin may reduce or abolish chaperone function, also resulting in the accumulation of damaged crystallin proteins [31]. In young fibre cells of the lens cortex, physiological stress caused by the accumulation of damaged protein can prevent differentiation in to mature fibre cells [32]. Therefore, crystallin mutations can cause cataract as a result of aberrant protein folding and where the effect is particularly detrimental to the developing lens, may also cause anterior segment defects such as microphthalmia and microcornea secondary to microphakia (Fig. 3.2).

A330328_1_En_3_Fig2_HTML.gif


Fig. 3.2
Protein modelling to estimate variant mechanism pathogenicity: Identification of a variant that is predicted to be highly damaging to CRYBB2 protein structure in a family an autosomal dominant cataract and microphthalmia phenotype

Cataract can also occur in the absence of protein misfolding. Within lens fibres, extremely soluble and stable crystallin proteins exist at high concentration. They are tightly and regularly packaged in a highly ordered manner to create an even protein distribution [28]. Given that crystallins also vary in size, they are said to exist in polydisperse, short-range order. To achieve this arrangement, crystallins display repulsive charges on their protein surface [33]. Crystallin mutations that alter protein surface charges lead to altered interactions and reduced solubility that cannot be resolved by the α-crystallin chaperone [34, 35]. Such alterations are disruptive to the normal short-range protein order and subsequently result in the co-existence of pockets of high and low protein concentration. Protein-rich areas have a higher refractive index than protein-poor areas of the lens, thus causing light scattering that appears as opacity within the lens [36].


3.4 What are the Aetiological and Genetic Bases of Paediatric Cataract?



3.4.1 Incidence and Epidemiology


Congenital cataract has a calculated incidence of 1 per 10,000 live births in the UK, increasing to approximately 3.5 per 10,000 cases for childhood cataract [37]. Global estimates of congenital and childhood cataract are 1–6 per 10,000 in developed countries and 5–15 per 10,000 in developing countries [38], making cataract the leading cause of treatable blindness in children [37]. Causes of cataract in children include trauma, maternal TORCHS (toxoplasmosis, rubella, cytomegalovirus, herpes simplex and syphilis) infection (accounting for approximately 1 % of cases [39]), and intrauterine exposure to drugs or radiation. A large portion of paediatric cataracts are attributable to genetic variants or mutations, and in the majority of cases are inherited in a Mendelian fashion. Whilst the vast majority of unilateral cataract cases are idiopathic, it is estimated that 25–50 % of bilateral congenital and childhood cataract cases have a genetic basis [40, 41]. However, this is likely to be an underestimate since a number of apparently idiopathic cases will represent de novo dominant or recessive mutations [42]. Inherited cataracts can be grouped in to four main categories: (1) Isolated or non-syndromic cataracts; (2) Cataracts with extra-lenticular abnormalities; (3) Cataracts manifesting as a feature of a multi-system condition; (4) Cataracts presenting as a manifestation of an inborn-error of metabolism.


3.4.2 Genetic Aetiology


Inherited paediatric cataract can occur as a result of chromosomal rearrangements (Jamieson et al. 2007), trisomies (Down, Patau, Edwards syndromes); recurrent deletions (5p, 18q, 18p); triplet repeat disorders (e.g.- myotonic dystrophy [43]); mitochondrial disorders (e.g.- cytochrome C oxidase deficiency caused by MTCO1, [44]); loss of heterozygosity (e.g.- neurofibromatosis type 2 [45]) and microduplications/deletions [46, 47]. However, cataracts are most frequently caused by single nucleotide variations. Non-synonymous missense variants, single nucleotide base pair changes that alter an amino acid sequence, account for the vast majority of cataract-causing mutations in children. Since missense variants can have a variable effect on the function of the encoded protein of a gene, pathogenicity is difficult to assign in the absence of experimental evidence [48]. Congenital and childhood cataract is further complicated by extreme genetic heterogeneity. Mutations in over 100 genes have been associated with all types of the condition. Non-syndromic cataract, that is estimated to account for 70 % of inherited paediatric cataract cases [39], has been associated with around 25 genes, to date (Table 3.2). There are many more genes associated with syndromes that feature cataracts as an early manifestation (Table 3.4) [49]. Here, phenotypic ambiguity, overlap and complexity can preclude disease recognition and diagnosis.


Table 3.4
Examples of systemic conditions associated with congenital and childhood cataract














































































 
Syndrome

Phenotype

Gene symbol

Renal/Genitourinary

Peters-plus

CC

B3GALTL

Corneal opacities

ASD

Facial clefting

Brachydactyly

Short stature

Rhizomelia

Hypospadias

Hydronephrosis

Kidney and ureteral duplication

Smith-Lemli-Opitz

Cataract

DHCR7

Microcephaly

Learning difficulties

Hypotonia

Cryptochidism

Hypospadias

Renal agenesis

Cystic kidney

Lowe Syndrome

CC

OCRL1

Microphthalmia

Glaucoma

Hearing loss

Short stature

Cryptorchidism

Proximal renal tubular acidosis

Renal fanconi

Joint hypermobility

Central nervous system

Warburg- MICRO syndrome

CC

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Nov 21, 2017 | Posted by in OPHTHALMOLOGY | Comments Off on The Role of Molecular Genetics in the Assessment of Children with Congenital Cataract

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access