Fig. 1
Macular edema: fluid accumulation within and/or under the retina. Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) section (a) and histology (b) of a healthy human retina. Note the different retinal layers from the choroid to the vitreous cavity: RPE retinal pigment epithelium, ELM external limiting membrane, IS/OS photoreceptors inner segment/outer segment junction, ONL outer nuclear layer, OPL outer plexiform layer, INL inner nuclear layer, IPL inner plexiform layer, GCL ganglion cell layer, ILM internal limiting membrane, RNFL retinal nerve fiber layer. Diabetic macular edema imaged on SD-OCT (c) and histology of a human macula presenting macular edema (d), diplaying an increase in retinal thickness (red arrows), the formation of intraretinal cysts (green stars), and the accumulation of subretinal fluid (short red arrows)
ME can manifest in nearly all retinal diseases at various phases of their development. Most frequently ME is associated with ischemia/hypoxia and/or inflammation. Systemic factors such as increased blood pressure (hypertension) or reduced plasma oncotic pressure (hypoalbuminemia) can aggravate ME.
In physiologic conditions, active mechanisms permanently maintain the retina in a transparent and relatively dehydrated state. Fluid can enter in the retina from the vitreous, from the retinal vessels, and from the subretinal space through the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE). Fluid entry from the circulation into the retina is controlled by the inner blood-retinal barrier, formed by endothelial tight junctions, pericytes, astrocytes, and retinal Müller glia (RMG) [1], and by the outer retinal barrier, formed by the tight junction of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) [2]. Fluid exit through the RPE is ensured by active ion and water channels [3]. It is facilitated by the oncotic pressure-driven flow. Numerous ionic transports are strictly regulated in RPE cells and contribute to the outward flux from the subretinal space toward the choroid. RMG cells also play an important role in ion and water drainage from the inner retina toward the retinal vessels (Fig. 2). In physiologic conditions, potassium transport is associated with water drainage through Kir (inwardly rectifying potassium channels) and aquaporin (AQP) channels that are both expressed in RMG cells [4, 5]. The exact molecular partners of ion and water coupling are only partially known in the retina. It is accepted that Kir4.1 and AQP4, located in RMG cells around retinal vessels and in RMG end feet, are key players in this balance (Fig. 2). Moreover, tight-like junctions recently identified at the external limiting membrane (ELM) between RMG and photoreceptors control the passive movement of fluid in the outer retina (Fig. 3). Altogether, these different mechanisms act in a synchronized manner to control the retinal thickness.
Fig. 2
(a) Schematic representation of a retinal Müller glial cell illustrating its roles in ion and water drainage from the inner retina toward the retinal vessels. Potassium transport is associated with water drainage through Kir4.1 (inwardly rectifying potassium channels) and AQP4 (aquaporin) channels, both located close to the interface of the retinal Müller glial cell with retinal vessels and in retinal Müller glial end feet at the level of the internal limiting membrane. (b) Schematic representation of RPE cells illustrating the drainage of water and electrolytes from the subretinal space to the choroid via paracellular diffusion, facilitated diffusion, and active transport
Fig. 3
The structure of the external limiting membrane and distribution of retinal Müller glial cells. (a) Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography of healthy macula highlighting the hyperreflective signal attributed to the external limiting membrane. (b) Tight-like junctions and adherens junctions are found at the level of the external limiting membrane between retinal Müller glia and photoreceptors and rely on specialized molecular families including zonula occludens-1. Macular flat mounts from healthy monkeys (Macaca fascicularis) after immunostaining of glutamine synthetase (c, red), marker of Müller cells, zonula occludens-1 (d, green), and fusion of both fluorescence images (e). The colocalization of both markers (appearing yellow in e) indicates a close relationship between tight junctions and retinal Müller glial cells
The density of RMG cells is higher in the macula than in any other region of the retina. In addition, their morphology also differs, with a perifoveal portion orientated radially and almost parallel to the frontal plane [6, 7] which suggests that RMG cells exhibit different functions in the macula than in the periphery. Whether ion and water transport mechanisms also present specific features in the macula should be explored and could contribute to explain the specific location of edema in the macula.
Mechanisms Leading to ME
ME results from an imbalance between fluid entry and fluid exit leading to an accumulation of fluid within and/or under the retina and in the extracellular and/or in the intracellular media (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4
Mechanisms of macular edema. Macular edema results from an imbalance between fluid entry and fluid exit leading to an abnormal accumulation of fluid within and/or under the retina (*the contribution of the vitreous on the retinal fluid entry is limited)
The pathogenic mechanisms of ME can be classified as “vasogenic,” which reflects a vascular leakage with a volumetric influx of extracellular fluid or “cytotoxic” which reflects cell swelling induced by a volumetric increase in intracellular fluid.
Mechanisms Leading to Increased Retinal Fluid Entry or “Vasogenic” Mechanisms
Starling Equation
The Starling equation represents the movements of fluid in and out capillary vessels. It depends on capillary filtration, hydrostatic, and oncotic pressure – i.e., Starling forces.
The Starling equation reads as follows:
where:
J ν is the net fluid movement between compartments
P c is the capillary hydrostatic pressure
P i is the interstitial hydrostatic pressure
π c is the capillary oncotic pressure
π i is the interstitial oncotic pressure
K f is the filtration coefficient – a proportionality constant
σ is the reflection coefficient
In conditions such as inflammation and elevated intracapillary pressure, the forces and membrane parameters governing transendothelial flux enhance filtration and increase the interstitial accumulation of albumin. The increased oncotic pressure in the neuroretina reduces fluid absorption and leads to retinal edema.
Rupture of Retinal Barriers
Barrier properties of retinal blood vessels and the RPE are due mainly to the presence of complex tight junction networks between cells. Tight junction and adherens junctions are integral membrane structures connected to the actin cytoskeleton via different adaptor molecules. Tight junctions are constituted by occludins, claudins (particularly claudin 5), and junction-associated molecules (JAM) connected to PDZ domain-containing proteins (among which is zonula occludens-1) and associated with an atypical protein kinase responsible for the tightly regulated phosphorylation of junction proteins (e.g., protein kinase C zeta, PKCζ). Junction proteins are transmembrane adhesive molecules closely linked to the cytoskeleton and with polarization proteins in the RPE. Tight junction destabilization can result from alteration of phosphorylation enzyme activity (e.g., PKCζ in diabetes), reduction of tight junction protein expression (e.g., occludin in diabetes), alteration of the cytoskeleton (e.g., secondary to oxidative damage or activation of RhoA/ROCK1 pathway), calcium dynamics [8], cell loss or severe cell damage (e.g., in case of severe inflammatory processes), and degradation of tight junction molecules by activation of proteases [9]. During inflammation, the exact molecular mechanisms that lead to tight junction disruption remain imperfectly understood. The cross talk between microglia and endothelial cells could contribute to tight junction expression regulation [10], while actin-binding molecules could also control vascular permeability via various signaling mechanisms such as activation of small GTPases [11]. Several extracellular signals could also intervene through signaling pathways leading to phosphorylation of actin and/or junction proteins, leading to their displacement from the membrane to other subcellular compartments.
Mechanical stress can also contribute to tight junction rupture as observed in the RPE submitted to chronic pressure secondary to vascular or melanocytic tumors in the choroid or to choroidal vasodilation in central serous chorioretinopathy.
Soluble mediators inducing vascular and/or RPE permeability include cytokines, such us monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α), interleukins (IL-1b, IL-8, IL-6), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) family members, acute phase proteins, enzymes, plasma activation systems (contact system, complement factor system, coagulation factors, fibrinolysis factors), arachidonic acid metabolites, biogenic or vasoactive amines (histamine, serotonin), eosinophil granular proteins, neuropeptides, oxygen free radicals, and nitric oxide.
Vascular Abnormalities Associated with Enhanced Permeability
Besides alteration of the tight and adherens junction complexes, other abnormal vascular changes can lead to increased fluid entry, visualized by “leakage” of dye during fluorescein angiography. This is the case for retinal neovascularization proliferating at the surface of the retina, with immature and low parietal stabilization, aneurysmal dilation of retinal capillaries (leaky microaneurysms in diabetic retinopathy), and vascular telangiectasia associated with intense protein leakage (as observed in Type 1 idiopathic macular telangiectasia and Coats’ disease). Factors potentially increasing the vascular permeability include lower pericyte coverage, hemodynamic changes with focal occlusions and secondary endothelial alterations, and elevation of the intravascular pressure.
Factors inducing vascular abnormalization include ischemia through hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha (HIF-1a), VEGFA and placental growth factor (PGF), and oxidative stress through advanced glycation end products (AGE). In certain disorders, such as Type 2 idiopathic macular telangiectasia, they remain unknown. The role of microglial cells and RMG cells is now considered as important players in the development of retinal vascular diseases [12].
RPE Dysfunction
RPE dysfunction can contribute to fluid entry from the choroid into the subretinal space. This enhanced fluid entry does not strictly belong to the classical vasogenic mechanisms. Indeed, the RPE transports water from the subretinal space into the choroid without rupture of the RPE tight junctions. The important RPE absorption capacity is particularly obvious in case of retinal detachment. RPE transport of Cl− and K+ is thought to drive transepithelial water transport. But in physiologic basal conditions, the Cl− conductance is up to 70% of the total basolateral conductance. The transport rate of water through RPE is estimated between 1.4 and 11 μl/cm2/h [13]. Fluid absorption involves complex mechanisms operating in the apical and basolateral membranes of the RPE cells that involve Cl− transport, Na+/K+-ATPase activity, and Ca2+-activated, volume-activated, and/or cAMP-activated ion channels. These mechanisms are differentially regulated under light or dark conditions and are influenced by the circadian rhythm. Ion absorption in the RPE is accompanied by water transport through aquaporins [5, 14–16]. Calcium channels in the RPE were shown to regulate VEGF expression, suggesting a potential link between RPE ion transport and VEGF-induced permeability [17].
In pathological conditions such as diabetic retinopathy, changes in aquaporin expression were shown at the level of RPE [18].
Subretinal fluid accumulation resulting from alteration of fluid and ion transport across the RPE has also been suggested in central serous chorioretinopathy (Fig. 10a), but whether such changes per se are able to induce subretinal fluid in the absence of RPE barrier disruption has not been demonstrated.
Mechanisms Leading to Reduced Retinal Fluid Exit or “Cytotoxic” Mechanisms: Retinal Müller Glia Dysfunction
RMG drainage functions are altered in almost all retinal diseases associated with ischemia and inflammation, as well as in chronic hyperglycemia [19]. RMG cells play a central role in the hydro-ionic balance in the retina, absorbing water from the retinal tissue by water transport coupled to the potassium clearance function. Kir4.1 channels are localized in the RMG cells’ membrane around the vessels in physiologic conditions but undergo a change in localization and/or levels of expression in pathologic conditions. This leads to potassium excess within RMG cells, subsequent cellular swelling, and enhanced potassium levels in the extracellular milieu with increased osmotic pressure. Retinal cysts can at least in part result from RMG swelling and necrotic death [4, 20]. RMG cells also drive water flux in and out the vessels through AQP4 channels, which are also altered in pathologic states (Fig. 5).
Fig. 5
(a) Normal retina; (b) Diabetic retina. Retinal Müller glial cells in normal and diabetic retina. Retinal Müller glial cells drive water flux in and out the vessels through AQP4 and Kir4.1 channels, which are altered in pathologic states provoking macular edema. In the diabetic retina, the drainage capability of the retinal Müller glial cell is overwhelmed, and AQP4 and Kir4.1 are displaced toward the outer portion of the retinal Müller glial cell. Additional channels (AQP1 and AQP9) are also expressed at the cell surface. As a consequence of macular edema, glutamate accumulates, and its cellular toxicity contributes to the persistence of the macular edema
There are other evidences of the central role of RMG cells in ME formation such as pharmacotoxic ME induced by chemotherapy drugs, which presents with silent ME on fluorescein angiography. In these cases, drugs damaging the cytoskeleton can lead to pure cytotoxic edema without any clinically detectable vasogenic component.
Interestingly, studies have shown that potassium conductance decreases in the aging human retina favoring ME in elderly patients [21].
Mechanical Tractions
Any tractional force exerted at the vitreoretinal interface and/or under the retina can cause or aggravate ME (Fig. 6). Three hypotheses may explain the mechanical formation of ME: the deformations caused by traction on Müller cells, with subsequent metabolic impairment; the deformation of vessels with subsequent leakage from altered vascular walls; and the decreased interstitial hydrostatic pressure creating water, ion, and protein influx within the neuroretinal tissue.
Fig. 6
Mechanical traction-induced macular edema. (a) Vitreomacular tractions leading to macular edema associated with an epiretinal membrane. (b) Epiretinal membrane and vitreomacular adhesion leading to cystoid macular edema and an irregular retinal surface
In physiologic conditions, vitreous collagen fibers distribute tractional forces evenly to the vitreoretinal interface, where they are intertwined with RMG cell end feet at the internal limiting membrane (ILM). In case of vitreomacular traction exerted after partial vitreous detachment, the same tractional forces are applied locally to fewer RMG cells. This may lead to chronic RMG cell irritation and local release of inflammatory mediators, which in turn may facilitate vascular leakage [22]. The same mechanical process may account for vascular alterations, particularly because vessels are located in the inner retinal layers. Finally, persistent tractional forces applied to the vitreoretinal interface may lead to a decreased interstitial hydrostatic pressure within the neuroretinal tissue. By diminishing the interstitial pressure term in Starling’s law, this traction results in an increased fluid influx from the vascular compartment [23, 24].
These processes probably occur simultaneously in the pathophysiology of mechanical ME. Epiretinal membranes, macular pucker, vitreomacular traction due to abnormal vitreous adhesion, and glial or glio-vascular proliferations observed in proliferative vitreoretinopathy following retinal detachment and proliferative diabetic retinopathy must be individually analyzed to understand their role in ME formation.
Causes of Macular Edema
ME can occur during the course of virtually every retinal disease at various phases of their evolution. The mechanisms of ME discussed above are intricate, but according to the causal disorder, certain mechanisms predominate.
Vasogenic Macular Edema
Retinal Vein Occlusion
Retinal vein occlusion leads to an increased intravascular pressure, blood-retinal barrier breakdown, and vascular leakage (Fig. 7a). Inner retinal hypoxia is associated with increased VEGF levels through HIF-1α, nitric oxide, and pro-inflammatory cytokines that contribute to the inner blood-retinal barrier rupture [25]. Hypertension, frequently associated with retinal vein occlusion, aggravates ME by further increasing the intracapillary hydrostatic pressure in the Starling equation. In addition, secondary hypoxic alterations of RMG cells may also lead to cytotoxic edema [26]. In cases of retinal vein occlusion with associated ischemia, excitotoxicity due to glutamate excess induces intracellular neuronal edema secondary to cellular energy failure [27]. Subretinal fluid is present in about half of central retinal vein occlusions and indicates that outer retinal barrier breakdown contributes to ME formation [28]. Indeed VEGF release also acts on the RPE barrier function through the VEGF receptor 1 (Flt-1), whose expression is under HIF-1α regulation [29].
Fig. 7
Various causes of vasogenic macular edema imaged by color fundus photography and OCT. (a) Central retinal vein occlusion, characterized by flame-shaped hemorrhages, venous tortuosity, and few cotton-wool spots. Macular edema manifests by the intraretinal and subretinal accumulation of fluid. (b) Diabetic retinopathy and diabetic macular edema, displaying numerous dot-blot hemorrhages and lipid exudates. Optical coherence tomography shows diffuse cystoid macular edema and focal hyperreflective dots corresponding to the exudates. (c) Hypertensive retinopathy characterized by peripapillary distribution of cotton-wool spots, hemorrhages, and macular edema with subretinal fluid seen on optical coherence tomography
Diabetic Macular Edema (DME)
The pathogenesis of DME is complex and multifactorial. Before any microangiopathy is clinically observed, intraretinal local inflammation (i.e., neuroinflammation) causes neuronal damage [30, 31]. Specifically, activation of microglial cells contributes to the local release of nitric oxide, TNF-α, interleukins, and VEGF [32]. In physiologic conditions, microglia trafficking contributes to retinal homeostasis. Active clearance of microglial cells through RPE transcytosis was demonstrated in the rodent retina, which prevents subretinal accumulation of activated cells. With aging, this active clearance increases in order to compensate for enhanced microglial activation to age-related debris, while it decreases in case of diabetic retinopathy as a consequence of alteration of cytoskeleton plasticity [32, 33]. Accumulation of microglia in the diabetic retina was also demonstrated to occur in humans [34, 35].