Eyelid Malpositions
ENTROPION
ACUTE SPASTIC ENTROPION
Acute spastic entropion is the result of eyelid swelling along with orbicularis spasm that results in a temporary in-turning of the eyelid. A cycle of corneal irritation from the entropion, causing more eyelid spasm and more irritation, must be broken, so the eyelid can return to normal. Many of these patients will have underlying involutional changes (laxity) that may result in a recurrent entropion.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: More common in older patient population
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Ocular irritation or inflammation causes continued forced blinking and closure of the eye. This will lead to in-turning of the lower eyelid in eyelids that have involutional changes predisposing them to entropion (see Involutional Entropion section).
History
• Recent surgery on the eye or recent onset of ocular irritation
Examination
• Lower eyelid entropion (Fig. 5-1) with associated involutional factors, such as horizontal laxity and orbicularis override
• In addition, there is a separate identifiable irritant to the eye.
• This irritant may be keratitis, foreign body, suture, or just inflammation postoperatively.
Differential Diagnosis
• Involutional entropion
• Cicatricial entropion
Pathophysiology
• Involutional changes of the eyelid allow the forced closure of the eyelid orbicularis muscle to override the tarsus and drive the eyelid margin inward toward the eye.
Treatment
• Treatment of the underlying ocular irritation or inflammation will resolve some cases.
• This involves treating the ocular irritation and stabilizing the eyelid to halt the additional irritation the eyelid is causing.
• Stabilizing the eyelid may involve taping the eyelid out or Quickert sutures.
• Some cases will then resolve; others will suffer from an involutional entropion and will need more extensive surgery.
Prognosis
• Excellent. Recurrence in patients with significant involutional factors of the eyelid may develop an involutional entropion at a later time.
INVOLUTIONAL ENTROPION
Eyelid laxity, both horizontally and vertically, predisposes to the instability of the lower eyelid. The additional factor required is the ability of the patient’s orbicularis muscle to override the tarsus and drive the eyelid inward. Patients present with red, irritated eyes from the eyelid margin, and the eyelashes come into contact with the eye itself.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: More common in older patient population
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Horizontal laxity and orbicularis override result in inversion of the eyelid.
History
• Acute onset of eye irritation. This irritation is sometimes intermittent in nature and becomes more constant.
Examination
• Inverted lower eyelid with inferior corneal superficial punctate keratitis (SPK) or corneal abrasion (Fig. 5-2)
• Entropion is usually associated with horizontal eyelid laxity.
• Orbicularis muscle override is often noted as fullness over the tarsal plate when the lid is entropic.
• The entropion can be intermittent and not always present on examination.
• Administering topical anesthetic drops in the eye, having the patient close the eyes and forcefully and look downward will usually bring out the entropion.
Differential Diagnosis
• Cicatricial entropion
• Acute spastic entropion
Pathophysiology
• Aging of eyelid tissues results in laxity and stretching of supporting structures.
Treatment
• Surgical correction is based on correcting the factors contributing to the entropion, usually horizontal shortening of the eyelid and tightening the eyelid retractors in any of multiple ways.
CICATRICIAL ENTROPION
Cicatricial entropion is caused by conjunctival scarring pulling the eyelid inward. Generally, treatment is surgical, but defining and treating the cause of the conjunctival scarring must be done first; otherwise most cases will recur. Cicatricial entropion can occur in the upper or lower eyelid.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Any age
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Scar tissue on the conjunctival surfaces results in shortening of the posterior lamella, physically pulling the eyelid inward.
• Factors include:
Surgery
Conjunctival scarring diseases (e.g., ocular cicatricial pemphigoid, Stevens-Johnson syndrome, trachoma)
Trauma
Conjunctival burns (e.g., chemical)
Antiglaucoma drops
History
• Chronic low-grade inflammation over months to years results in the entropion that then causes more irritation.
• The other scenario is a history of trauma or surgery, resulting in an entropion and associated irritation.
Examination
• Careful evaluation of the conjunctiva for signs of scarring, causing inversion of the eyelid.
• This may include evaluation of the other eyelids to determine if the entropion is isolated or involving all four eyelids, which may help determine the etiology (Fig. 5-3).
Special Considerations
• Must determine the etiology of the conjunctival scarring before treating the entropion
• Any progressive disease must be quieted before surgery can be done on the eyelids.
Differential Diagnosis
• Acute spastic entropion
• Involutional entropion
Laboratory Tests
• Conjunctival biopsy with immunofluorescence testing if ocular cicatricial pemphigoid is suspected
Treatment
• Determine the etiology of the conjunctival scarring.
• Quiet any active disease.
• Surgical correction of the entropion with a marginal rotation or buccal mucosal graft is then the treatment of choice.
ECTROPION
INVOLUTIONAL ECTROPION
Involutional ectropion has the same involutional factors as in an involutional entropion (e.g., horizontal laxity, vertical instability). These patients do not have hypertrophic, spastic orbicularis muscle to override, so the unstable eyelid sags outward instead of being driven inward. Symptoms are less acute and not as severe as in involutional entropion. Many patients will have mild involutional ectropions and may be asymptomatic.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Incidence increases as age increases.
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Eyelid tissue laxity, especially horizontal laxity
History
• Insidious onset of ocular irritation and/or tearing
• Patient may note redness and inflammation of the eyelid margin.
Examination
• Eyelid sagging inferiorly and away from the globe surface (Fig. 5-4)
• Must look for the amount of horizontal laxity, corneal exposure, and stenosis of the lacrimal puncta
Special Considerations
• Tarsal ectropion is complete eversion of the eyelid and indicates detachment of the lower eyelid retractors.
• This condition must be recognized, because it requires both horizontal tightening and reattachment of the retractors.
Differential Diagnosis
• Cicatricial ectropion
• Paralytic ectropion
Treatment
• Mild ectropion with only mild exposure symptoms can sometimes be treated with ocular lubrication.
• Definitive treatment involves horizontal eyelid shortening and possible punctoplasty.
PARALYTIC ECTROPION
Paralytic ectropion is the result of temporary or permanent seventh cranial nerve palsy. The lower eyelid sags away from the globe, resulting in loss of protection of the eye and inability of the lacrimal system to collect tears. Patients with less severe palsy and other eye protective mechanisms intact present with tearing. Patients with more severe palsies and poor eye protection mechanisms present with corneal breakdown.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Any age
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Facial palsy etiologies include
Bell’s palsy
Surgery: intracranial or facial
Stroke
Tumor
History
• Previous onset of facial palsy
• Depending on the severity of the facial palsy, the ectropion may have onset at the same time or the eyelid may slowly sag with time.
• The severity of the condition depends on the severity of the paralysis, corneal sensation, and ocular lubrication.
Examination
• The lower eyelid is found to be sagging away from the globe (Fig. 5-5).
• Evaluate severity of facial palsy, degree of ectropion, amount of corneal exposure, amount of lagophthalmos, and presence of an intact Bell phenomenon.
Special Considerations
• Must check for corneal sensation because loss of corneal sensation will make all exposure symptoms much worse
• Any unexplained facial palsy must be worked up.
Differential Diagnosis
• Bell palsy versus nonresolving facial palsy
Treatment
• Treatment depends on the anticipated duration of the paralysis.
• If spontaneous improvement is anticipated, then treatment with lubrication and a temporary tarsorrhaphy if severe corneal problems are present is indicated.
• If corneal exposure is still a problem with lubrication use and the paralysis is long term, then horizontal eyelid tightening is used to treat the paralytic ectropion.
• Placing a gold weight in the upper eyelid may also be required. Rarely, a permanent tarsorrhaphy may be needed.
CICATRICIAL ECTROPION
Cicatricial ectropion is caused by mechanical shortening of the anterior lamellae of the eyelid pulling the eyelid down and outward. This results in tearing and corneal exposure. More common in the lower eyelid but can occur in the upper eyelid.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Any age
• Gender: More common in males because of higher incidence of traumatic events
• Etiology: Scarring of the anterior lamellae of the eyelid pulls the eyelid outward. The etiologies include
Trauma
Surgery
Dermatitis
Skin carcinoma
History
• May include a specific history, such as trauma or surgery
• If a chronic dermatologic condition is the cause of the scarring, this may be a known or a previously unrecognized condition.
Examination
• External scarring or skin changes are noted on the upper, or more commonly on the lower, eyelid.
• This scarring results in shortening of the eyelid skin and out-turning of the eyelid margin (Fig. 5-6A).
Special Considerations
• Must always consider a skin carcinoma as the possible cause of scarring of the skin. If the cause is unclear, a biopsy is needed.
Differential Diagnosis
• Important to differentiate involutional ectropion from those with cicatricial changes
Treatment
• Treatment of any underlying dermatologic condition is important.
• In traumatic or postsurgical cases, the scarring should be left for 6 months or longer unless exposure or other problems necessitate earlier treatment.
• Treatment involves lysis of any deep scar tissue with horizontal tightening.
• If the skin shortening is severe, full-thickness skin grafts will be required.
• Skin grafts have the potential for scarring and a cosmetically noticeable area at the graft site (Fig. 5-6B).
MECHANICAL ECTROPION
Mechanical ectropion is a rare cause of ectropion in which a mass of some type pushes the eyelid outward. There are usually associated involutional changes that allow the eyelid to be pushed outward.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Older patients
• Gender: Equal occurrence in males and females
• Etiology: Gravity pulls the eyelid away from the eye or pushes the eyelid away from the eye secondary to a mass. Causes of the mass effect include
Dermatochalasis
Edema
Chalazion
Eyelid tumor (e.g., hemangioma, inclusion cyst)
History
• Patient may be asymptomatic, have symptoms of corneal irritation, or have redness and irritation of the eyelid.
Examination
• Must determine the degree of involutional changes of the eyelid as well as the etiology of the mass distorting the eyelid
• The amount of corneal exposure and any corneal scarring should also be noted (Fig. 5-7).
Differential Diagnosis
• Involutional ectropion
• Cicatricial ectropion
• Paralytic ectropion
Treatment
• Excision of the mass and correction of the involutional factors of the eyelid
Prognosis
• Good if the mass can be eliminated
SYMBLEPHARON
Symblepharon is scarring between the bulbar and palpebral conjunctiva. This may be associated with active inflammation, or there may be no inflammatory signs.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Any age
• Gender: More frequent in women
• Etiology: The following can result in scarring of two conjunctival surfaces:
Chronic blepharitis
Previous trauma
Conjunctival scarring diseases (e.g., ocular cicatricial pemphigoid, Stevens-Johnson syndrome)
Atopic disease
Eyelid surgery
Conjunctival burns
Chronic glaucoma drops, especially miotics
History
• There may be no history, just asymptomatic symblepharon noted on examination.
• Patients with history of eye or eyelid trauma or inflammation may also have symblepharon.
Examination
• Scarring of the conjunctival surfaces may be very subtle with slight inferior fornix shortening, or it may be very obvious with large conjunctival bands between the eye and eyelid (Fig. 5-8).
• Must be sure to examine under the upper lid for conjunctival scarring, because early signs are sometimes more obvious there
Special Considerations
• It is important to determine the cause of the symblepharon.
• If asymptomatic, the symblepharon may require no treatment except looking for the cause of the scarring.
• Ruling out a progressive conjunctival scarring disease, such as ocular cicatricial pemphigoid, is important.
Differential Diagnosis
• The differential diagnosis involves determining the cause of the symblepharon, not whether the process is a symblepharon.
Laboratory Tests
• Conjunctival scarring of unknown etiology requires a conjunctival biopsy with immunofluorescence testing to rule out ocular cicatricial pemphigoid.
• In rare cases, squamous cell carcinoma may cause symblepharon; therefore, pathologic evaluation should be considered in select cases.
Treatment
• None for mild symblepharon
• Monitoring for progression is important.
• Significant symblepharon may cause trichiasis and cicatricial entropion, which, in turn, may require treatment.
TRICHIASIS
Trichiasis is an acquired misdirection of eyelashes. Trichiasis may be focal, as is seen after eyelid trauma in the area of the laceration. The process may be diffuse with eyelid scarring and lashes along the entire eyelid margin.
Epidemiology and Etiology
• Age: Any age. Nontraumatic causes are rare in childhood. More common with increasing age
• Gender: More common in females
• Etiology: Lash follicles are distorted and become misdirected with scarring of the eyelid. Chronic eyelid inflammation may result in growth of misdirected lashes. Chronic blepharitis, eyelid trauma, and conjunctival scarring diseases can all cause trichiasis.
History
• Patients will often have a history of chronic eye irritation and inflammation. They may also have a long history of eyelash problems. There may be a history of eyelid trauma or surgery.
Examination
• Eyelashes are seen rubbing on the eyelid surface (Fig. 5-9).
• The amount of corneal changes depends on the number of lashes and duration. There may be just SPK or there may be corneal scarring.