Abstract
Background
Midline destructive lesions (MDLs) of the nose are a diagnostic dilemma due to an extensive differential diagnosis and vague presenting signs and symptoms. Etiologies may be neoplastic, autoimmune, traumatic, infectious, or unknown.
Study Design
Case series and review of the literature were done.
Methods
Medical records of 8 patients presenting with an MDL were reviewed.
Results
Each patient received nasal endoscopy, computed tomography scan of the sinuses, laboratory workup, culture (aerobes, anaerobes, fungus, and acid-fast bacilli), and biopsy with flow cytometry. Laboratory tests included complete blood count, basic metabolic panel, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, angiotensin-converting enzyme, antineutrophil antibodies, rheumatoid factor, anti-Ro and anti-La antibodies, Epstein-Barr virus antibodies, coccidiomycosis serology, HIV antibodies, fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption, classic antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies, perinuclear antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody, proteinase 3, and myeloperoxidase. Choice of diagnostic study was individualized for each patient. Two patients were diagnosed with natural killer/T-cell lymphoma, 2 were diagnosed with Wegener’s granulomatosis, and 4 remained idiopathic, despite the extensive workup. A diagnostic algorithm to aid in the approach to MDLs is presented.
Conclusions
The diagnosis of MDLs remains difficult but is aided by a systematic approach and familiarity with multiple diagnostic techniques. It is imperative to take multiple tissue specimens from various sites, send them fresh, and communicate suspicion of lymphoma. Despite diagnostic advances and improved understanding of the diseases underlying MDLs, an etiology is often not identified.
1
Introduction
Midline destructive lesions (MDLs) of the face were first reported in 1897 , but naming of MDLs started when Stewart reported 10 cases of a chronic destructive midfacial process in 1922. Later, Williams began to use the term lethal midline granuloma to describe a destructive process of the nasal cavity of unknown etiology. Since that time, a variety of terms have been used to describe MDLs involving the nose and paranasal sinuses, including idiopathic midline granuloma, idiopathic midline destructive disease (IMDD), midline nonhealing granuloma, lethal midline granuloma, polymorphic reticulosis, and Stewart syndrome, among others . Common to all is the ulcerative process that occurs in the nose characterized by epithelium and cartilage loss with crusting that may result in loss of nasal structure, support, and, ultimately, cosmetic and functional deformity.
The diagnostic approach to MDLs of the nose poses a difficult diagnostic dilemma. The variability of the underlying pathologic processes and nonspecific presenting symptoms makes the diagnosis complex. Although serologic testing, immunophenotyping, and genetic testing attribute most MDLs to Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG) or natural killer/T-cell–type non–Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NKTL) , the differential diagnosis at presentation remains extensive if systemic symptoms are absent. Herein, we discuss 8 patients who presented with an MDL, we review the current tools available for diagnosis, and we present a diagnostic algorithm.
2
Case series
Institutional review board approval was obtained for review of 8 consecutive patients who presented with various undiagnosed MDLs during 2007. Each received nasal endoscopy, computed tomography (CT) scan of the sinuses, laboratory workup, culture, and biopsy with flow cytometry. Laboratory testing included complete blood count, basic metabolic panel, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE), antineutrophil antibodies, rheumatoid factor, anti-Ro and anti-La antibodies, Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) antibodies, coccidiomycosis serology, HIV antibodies, rapid plasma reagin, fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption, classic antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (cANCAs), perinuclear antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (pANCAs), proteinase 3 (PR3), and myeloperoxidase (MPO). The spectrum of laboratory studies used was individualized for each patient. Cultures included aerobes, anaerobes, and fungi, and acid-fast bacilli. Table 1 shows pertinent patient history and physical, workup, and final diagnosis.
Age (y)/sex | History | Physical examination | Pertinent diagnostic tests | Diagnosis |
---|---|---|---|---|
1: 42/female | 1-y history of nasal and maxillary pain and nasal crusting intermittent joint pain | Saddle nose deformity | CT : septal perforation | IMDD |
Gingivolabial-nasal fistula | Laboratory tests : negative | |||
Atrophic inferior turbinates | Culture : group C streptococci | |||
Periorbital edema | Cartilaginous septal perforation | Biopsy : focal areas of ulceration and necrosis with squamous metaplasia | ||
history of smoking | Significant crusting | |||
2: 49/female | 3 y history of facial swelling, congestion, drainage, pain, and pressure | Erythema of lower two thirds of nose ulceration of right nasal ala | CT : diffuse inflammation | WG |
Destruction of cartilaginous septum | CXR : negative | |||
history of arthritis and smoking | Granular-appearing mucopurulent mucosa | Laboratory tests : cANCA+, pANCA+, PR3-ANCA+ | ||
Gross destruction endonasally | Culture : Staphylococcus aureus , Pseudomonas aeruginosa | |||
Biopsy : chronic inflammatory infiltrate | ||||
3: 63/male | 2 y of recurrent severe epistaxis | Ulcerated mucosa with mucopurulent discharge | CT : septal perforation | IMDD |
Hyposmia | Septal perforation | CXR / CT chest : multiple calcified lung nodules bilaterally | ||
Chronic hearing discomfort | Gross destruction of endonasal structure | Laboratory tests : elevated ESR | ||
history of arthritis | Bilaterally dehiscent lamina papyracea | Culture : S aureus | ||
Biopsy : inflammation and granulation | ||||
4: 52/female | Long history of congestion, hyposmia, nasal drainage, right facial pain and headache, and episodic epistaxis | Anterior septal defect | CT : diffuse mucosal thickening | IMDD |
Truncated right inferior turbinate | Laboratory tests : ESR elevated, anticardiolipin+ | |||
Granulation tissue | Biopsy : inflammation and granulation | |||
history of CRS, asthma, atopic dermatitis | Diffuse edema | |||
5: 60/male | 3 wk of left-sided facial erythema, swelling, and congestion | Necrotic friable debris between the septum and lateral nasal wall bilaterally | CT : ethmoidal soft tissue mass | NKTL |
history of CRS and asthma | Diffuse fibrinous exudates | Biopsy : necrosis, infiltrate of mostly medium to large transformed lymphocytes with irregular nuclear membranes visible nucleoli. Frequent mitoses. | ||
Flow cytometry : CD45−, CD34−, CD56+, TIA1+, CD33−, cytoplasmic CD3−, CD5−, CD8− | ||||
PET : multiple increased uptake sites | ||||
6: 34/female | Postnasal drip/rhinorrhea | Polypoid disease | CT : moderate mucosal thickening and opacification of the sinuses | WG |
Hyposmia | Osteitic bone changes | |||
Headaches and maxillary facial pressure | Laboratory tests : antineutrophil antibodies+, cANCA+ | |||
Green nasal drainage | Biopsy : necrotizing palisading granulomas | |||
Lacy rash on extremities and migratory arthralgias | ||||
history of CRS status post FESS and asthma | ||||
7: 42/male | 6 wk of progressive nasal obstruction and facial pain after septoplasty and FESS | Anterior septal perforation | CT : septal defect and bilateral nasal cavity opacification with erosion of the inferior turbinate bones and medial maxillary walls | NKTL |
Friable tissue overlying the bilateral inferior and middle turbinates | Biopsy : histopathology and flow cytometry confirmed angiocentric monomorphic T-cell infiltrate | |||
Erosion of the superior alveolus | ||||
8: 57/male | Epistaxis | Saddle nose deformity | CT : normal | IMDD |
Nasal crusting | Nodularity of the septum and inferior turbinates bilaterally | Laboratory tests : ESR elevated | ||
history of Crohn’s disease | Biopsy : chronic inflammation, fibrosis, focal necrosis |
2
Case series
Institutional review board approval was obtained for review of 8 consecutive patients who presented with various undiagnosed MDLs during 2007. Each received nasal endoscopy, computed tomography (CT) scan of the sinuses, laboratory workup, culture, and biopsy with flow cytometry. Laboratory testing included complete blood count, basic metabolic panel, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE), antineutrophil antibodies, rheumatoid factor, anti-Ro and anti-La antibodies, Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) antibodies, coccidiomycosis serology, HIV antibodies, rapid plasma reagin, fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption, classic antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (cANCAs), perinuclear antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (pANCAs), proteinase 3 (PR3), and myeloperoxidase (MPO). The spectrum of laboratory studies used was individualized for each patient. Cultures included aerobes, anaerobes, and fungi, and acid-fast bacilli. Table 1 shows pertinent patient history and physical, workup, and final diagnosis.
Age (y)/sex | History | Physical examination | Pertinent diagnostic tests | Diagnosis |
---|---|---|---|---|
1: 42/female | 1-y history of nasal and maxillary pain and nasal crusting intermittent joint pain | Saddle nose deformity | CT : septal perforation | IMDD |
Gingivolabial-nasal fistula | Laboratory tests : negative | |||
Atrophic inferior turbinates | Culture : group C streptococci | |||
Periorbital edema | Cartilaginous septal perforation | Biopsy : focal areas of ulceration and necrosis with squamous metaplasia | ||
history of smoking | Significant crusting | |||
2: 49/female | 3 y history of facial swelling, congestion, drainage, pain, and pressure | Erythema of lower two thirds of nose ulceration of right nasal ala | CT : diffuse inflammation | WG |
Destruction of cartilaginous septum | CXR : negative | |||
history of arthritis and smoking | Granular-appearing mucopurulent mucosa | Laboratory tests : cANCA+, pANCA+, PR3-ANCA+ | ||
Gross destruction endonasally | Culture : Staphylococcus aureus , Pseudomonas aeruginosa | |||
Biopsy : chronic inflammatory infiltrate | ||||
3: 63/male | 2 y of recurrent severe epistaxis | Ulcerated mucosa with mucopurulent discharge | CT : septal perforation | IMDD |
Hyposmia | Septal perforation | CXR / CT chest : multiple calcified lung nodules bilaterally | ||
Chronic hearing discomfort | Gross destruction of endonasal structure | Laboratory tests : elevated ESR | ||
history of arthritis | Bilaterally dehiscent lamina papyracea | Culture : S aureus | ||
Biopsy : inflammation and granulation | ||||
4: 52/female | Long history of congestion, hyposmia, nasal drainage, right facial pain and headache, and episodic epistaxis | Anterior septal defect | CT : diffuse mucosal thickening | IMDD |
Truncated right inferior turbinate | Laboratory tests : ESR elevated, anticardiolipin+ | |||
Granulation tissue | Biopsy : inflammation and granulation | |||
history of CRS, asthma, atopic dermatitis | Diffuse edema | |||
5: 60/male | 3 wk of left-sided facial erythema, swelling, and congestion | Necrotic friable debris between the septum and lateral nasal wall bilaterally | CT : ethmoidal soft tissue mass | NKTL |
history of CRS and asthma | Diffuse fibrinous exudates | Biopsy : necrosis, infiltrate of mostly medium to large transformed lymphocytes with irregular nuclear membranes visible nucleoli. Frequent mitoses. | ||
Flow cytometry : CD45−, CD34−, CD56+, TIA1+, CD33−, cytoplasmic CD3−, CD5−, CD8− | ||||
PET : multiple increased uptake sites | ||||
6: 34/female | Postnasal drip/rhinorrhea | Polypoid disease | CT : moderate mucosal thickening and opacification of the sinuses | WG |
Hyposmia | Osteitic bone changes | |||
Headaches and maxillary facial pressure | Laboratory tests : antineutrophil antibodies+, cANCA+ | |||
Green nasal drainage | Biopsy : necrotizing palisading granulomas | |||
Lacy rash on extremities and migratory arthralgias | ||||
history of CRS status post FESS and asthma | ||||
7: 42/male | 6 wk of progressive nasal obstruction and facial pain after septoplasty and FESS | Anterior septal perforation | CT : septal defect and bilateral nasal cavity opacification with erosion of the inferior turbinate bones and medial maxillary walls | NKTL |
Friable tissue overlying the bilateral inferior and middle turbinates | Biopsy : histopathology and flow cytometry confirmed angiocentric monomorphic T-cell infiltrate | |||
Erosion of the superior alveolus | ||||
8: 57/male | Epistaxis | Saddle nose deformity | CT : normal | IMDD |
Nasal crusting | Nodularity of the septum and inferior turbinates bilaterally | Laboratory tests : ESR elevated | ||
history of Crohn’s disease | Biopsy : chronic inflammation, fibrosis, focal necrosis |