Abstract
This report describes a three generation family with late onset bilateral sensorineural hearing impairment (BLSNHI) and tinnitus in which a novel mutation in the COCH gene was identified after a genome-wide linkage approach. The COCH gene is one of the few genes clinically examined when investigating the etiology of autosomal dominant late onset hearing impairment. Initially mutations in the COCH gene were only reported in exons 4 and 5, coding for the LCCL protein domain. More recently, additional mutations have been identified in exon 12, the only mutations identified outside of the LCCL domain. Currently clinical genetic testing for the COCH gene primarily focuses on identifying mutations in these three exons. In this study, we identify a novel mutation in the COCH gene in exon 11, which, like the exon 12 mutations, falls within the vWFA2 protein domain. This finding reinforces the need for clinical genetic screening of the COCH gene to be expanded beyond the current limited exon screening, as there is now more evidence to support that mutations in other areas of this gene are also causative of a similar form of late onset BLSNHI.
1
Introduction
The COCH gene, located on the long arm of chromosome 14 (14q12-q13), is one of the few genes causative of late onset bilateral sensorineural hearing impairment (BLSNHI) when mutated. Mutations in this gene were first reported in 1996 . The protein product of this gene, cochlin, is expressed in the cochlea and the vestibular system of the inner ear. The COCH protein makes up 70% of inner ear proteins . It assists in structural support, sound processing and maintenance of balance. Due to the large contribution COCH makes to inner ear proteins, it follows that mutations in this protein were found to interfere with disulfide bonds and proper protein folding and results in general structural disturbances affecting critical cochlear functions that are essential for hearing . Effects of mutations in the COCH gene have been found to cause non-syndromic autosomal dominant sensorineural deafness type 9 (DFNA9). Mutations were initially identified in exon 4 , resulting in a form of progressive BLSNHI caused by disruption of neural receptors in the inner ear and nerve pathways to the auditory centers of the brain receiving sound information. Mutant cochlin proteins may also lead to abnormal acidophilic deposits in the inner ear that could contribute to DFNA9 BLSNHI by cutting off, or causing degeneration of, dendrite fibers . Individuals with DFNA9 BLSNHI exhibit progressive late onset hearing impairment with onset usually prior to the fourth or fifth decade. Onset typically is in the high frequencies, progressing to include lower frequencies, and generally resulting in severe hearing impairment by the sixth decade of life. COCH mutations also frequently lead to vestibular dysfunction and balance problems.
The COCH gene is routinely screened for mutations in patients with late onset hearing impairment. Clinical mutational analysis for this gene until recently only encompassed exons 4 and 5, both of which encode the Limulus factor C, Coch-5b2, and Lg11 [LCCL] domain, since these were the only exons in which mutations had been found. The first mutation found outside of the LCCL domain was a c.1625 G > T transversion in exon 12 which is in the von Willebrand factor A2 (vWFA2) domain . Recent clinical mutational analysis has extended to include this exon . This protein domain is best known for its involvement in cell adhesion in extracellular matrix proteins, such as collagen . The von Willebrand Factor is itself a protein secreted from endothelial cells that works as a coagulation protein in blood . Cysteines flanking the vWF domain, A1 and A2, form a disulfide bond and mutations in the vWFA2 domain are likely to disrupt this bond, interfering with normal platelet binding activity . Mutations in this domain of the COCH gene would disrupt interactions with collagens and other extracellular matrix proteins and affect structural stability in the inner ear. This is in keeping with the effect of other COCH mutations, which also demonstrate various deleterious effects on inner ear integrity.
To date nine mutations have been identified in the COCH gene, all localized to within exons 4, 5, and 12 . In this study, we report a 3 generation extended family in which a novel mutation was identified in the COCH gene in exon 11, in the vWFA2 protein domain, the same domain also encoded by exon 12. The mutation is a heterozygous 18 base pair deletion, NM_001135058:c.1196_1213del, resulting in an in-frame deletion of 6 amino acids, p.Ile399_Ala404del. This novel mutation has not previously been implicated in DFNA9 related BLSNHI and is not currently screened for by most clinically available tests for COCH mutations. Additionally, all previously reported mutations in the COCH gene have been point mutations, while this mutation is an in frame deletion of 6 amino acids.
Consistent with other mutations in the COCH gene, the hearing impairment present in the family reported here is late onset, first occurring in the third decade, and progressive, initially involving the higher frequencies and progressing to severe encompassing all frequencies over the next several decades. Tinnitus is also a common finding in affected family members. They had no noted balance problems or other common medical problems; all other mutations in this gene have led to some sort of vestibular impairment, making this family an exception.
2
Materials and methods
2.1
Research subjects and controls
All affected individuals from the studied family ( Fig. 1 ) and controls were enrolled in the study under a protocol of informed consent approved by the Institutional Review Board at The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. Blood samples were obtained from a total of 17 members of an extended family with hereditary hearing impairment. The DNA was extracted and DNA samples were prepared using the Puregene genomic DNA isolation kit (Qiagen, cat. 158467). Three affected subjects, known to have hearing impairment, are all from one nuclear family (III 6, IV 10, IV 12). One member of the extended family, subject (III 4), had an atypical form of hearing impairment from the rest of the family. Four individuals with available samples are below the expected age of onset of hearing impairment as seen in the affected family members. Samples were also available from nine individuals from the extended family who are above the age of expected onset, but do not exhibit symptoms. Additionally, 49 ethnically matched unrelated controls were sequenced.
2.2
Medical history
Medical histories and examinations were initially taken at a consultation of the three adults with hearing impairment: the proband (IV 10), his father (III 6), and his sister (IV 12). These histories included details on the progression of their hearing impairment, as well as any other significant medical concerns that may or may not have been related to their hearing impairment, and results of brain imaging. An extended family history was obtained and subsequently additional family members were evaluated and samples collected ( Fig. 1 ).
2.3
Preliminary mutation analysis
The proband underwent clinical mutational analysis of a hearing impairment panel that included the GJB2 , GJB6 , and SLC26A4 genes, the mtA1555G point mutations, and COCH gene screening (inclusive of exons 4 and 5). No mutations were identified.
2.4
Linkage analysis
All samples were analyzed using HumanHap610K SNP genotyping array (Illumina, San Diego CA) at the Center for Applied Genomics (CAG) at The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, using the manufacturer’s and CAG’s recommended quality control protocols as previously described . Linkage analysis was performed on the SNP array data as follows: 1) PLINK software package was used to remove Mendelian errors and SNPs in high linkage disequilibrium. 2) Merlin was used to try to identify loci of significant linkage. LOD scores were determined, using model-free (non-parametric) as well as model-based (parametric) linkage analysis. Model-based analysis assumed full penetrance under an autosomal dominant mode of inheritance. Individuals who were younger than the minimum age of onset of the hearing impairment were not included in the linkage analysis. Regions with negative LOD scores were eliminated.
2.5
COCH gene mutational analysis
Mutation analysis of the COCH gene was performed for all exons and flanking intron/exon boundaries as determined by the genomic reference sequence (NM_001135058) obtained from the UCSC Genome Browser ( http://genome.ucsc.edu ). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers were designed and all 12 exons were screened using PCR. DNA of affected individuals was screened initially. Once a mutation had been identified unaffected family members and family members with unknown clinical status (e.g. those too young to manifest hearing impairment) were screened for the mutation. The sequencing data were analyzed using Sequencher software (Sequencher 4.9, Gene Codes Corporation, Ann Arbor, MI). PCR was performed on a cDNA sample synthesized from RNA from the proband, using Invitrogen’s SuperScript TM First-Strand Synthesis System (Grand Island, NY), to further characterize the findings. DNA samples of 49 additional ethnically matched control samples were sequenced for the exon of interest.