Long-term outcomes of facial nerve schwannomas with favorable facial nerve function: tumor growth rate is correlated with initial tumor size




Abstract


Objective


The study aimed to report long-term outcomes of facial nerve schwannomas (FNS) with favorable facial nerve function by observation, and to discuss about the relationship between initial tumor size and tumor growth.


Methods


21 facial nerve schwannoma cases with favorable facial nerve function were managed by observation. They were divided into larger size group (size ≥ 10 mm) and smaller size group (size < 10 mm) according to initial tumor size.


Results


They were followed up for 6.4 ± 1.7 years. 18 of 21 cases (85.7%) maintained House–Brackmann Grade III or better. Growth rate of the tumors in larger size group was 72.7%, much higher than 10% in smaller size group (p < 0.05).


Conclusions


Observation was feasible for most FNS with favorable facial nerve function, and growth rate of the tumors was associated with tumor size.



Introduction


Facial nerve schwannomas (FNS) are mostly slow-growing tumors that may involve any segments of facial nerve, but have a predilection for labyrinthine segment/geniculate ganglion .


Complete tumor removal and nerve grafting invariably lead to House–Brackmann Grade III recovery at best . Apparently, it is a source of great distress to patients, especially those whose initial facial nerve function is normal or mildly abnormal. Thus, delayed surgical removal may be considered in those patients with favorable facial nerve function (not worse than Grade III). Observation with serial radiologic examinations may maintain facial nerve at a favorable level for a long period.


In the study, we reviewed a consecutive series of 21 patients with FNS who had favorable facial nerve function and were managed by observation. The long-term follow-up results of them were reported, and the affecting factors of tumor growth were discussed.





Materials and methods


The study covered a consecutive series of 21 patients with FNS who had favorable facial nerve function and accepted observation as the management. They visited a tertiary referral center between 1998 and 2009. There were 12 females and 9 males. Mean age was 37.30 ± 3.52 years (range, 22–70 years). Three-dimensional MRI examination and high-resolution CT of temporal bone were performed at the time of diagnosis. Then the patients underwent three-dimensional MRI examination once per year during the follow-up. Hearing level was measured by clinical audiometer.


Initial tumor size was defined as average of the tumor size on three dimensions of initial MRI image. Tumor growth was defined as an increase in the average tumor size (≥ 1 mm). The patients were divided into larger size group (≥ 10 mm) and smaller size group (< 10 mm) according to initial average size of the tumors. Moreover, they were also divided into normal facial nerve group and facial palsy group based on initial facial nerve function. Growth rate of the tumors in the groups was compared by Fisher’s exact test, and SPSS 18.0 software was used in statistical analysis.





Materials and methods


The study covered a consecutive series of 21 patients with FNS who had favorable facial nerve function and accepted observation as the management. They visited a tertiary referral center between 1998 and 2009. There were 12 females and 9 males. Mean age was 37.30 ± 3.52 years (range, 22–70 years). Three-dimensional MRI examination and high-resolution CT of temporal bone were performed at the time of diagnosis. Then the patients underwent three-dimensional MRI examination once per year during the follow-up. Hearing level was measured by clinical audiometer.


Initial tumor size was defined as average of the tumor size on three dimensions of initial MRI image. Tumor growth was defined as an increase in the average tumor size (≥ 1 mm). The patients were divided into larger size group (≥ 10 mm) and smaller size group (< 10 mm) according to initial average size of the tumors. Moreover, they were also divided into normal facial nerve group and facial palsy group based on initial facial nerve function. Growth rate of the tumors in the groups was compared by Fisher’s exact test, and SPSS 18.0 software was used in statistical analysis.





Results


Table 1 listed summary of the cases. They were followed up for 6.4 ± 1.7 years (range, 4–9 years). 7 cases had normal facial nerve function, and 14 patients were Grade II or Grade III at the first visit. 10 patients had mild or moderate hearing loss, and hearing level was obviously worsened (defined as rise of final hearing threshold by more than 5 dB) in 3 of 21 cases (14.3%).



Table 1

Summary of 21 cases with facial nerve schwannomas.






















































































































































































































































No. Symptoms Tumor location Initial FNF Final FNF Initial TS (mm) Tumor growth IHL (dB) FHL (dB) FU (y)
1 T GG, LS I I 13 No 10 10 9
2 FP GG II II 7 No 5 5 8
3 CHL, T GG, TS I I 11 No 35 35 6
4 RFP GG, TS II III 5 No 5 5 5
5 V, SNHL CPA, IAC III VI 15 Yes 35 40 7
6 V, SNHL IAC, GG I II 14 Yes 40 70 4
7 SNHL IAC I I 15 No 30 35 7
8 FP, SNHL IAC,GG III III 7 No 50 45 6
9 FP, T TS, MS II II 5 No 15 15 4
10 SNHL, V IAC, GG I III 14 Yes 55 55 6
11 SNHL, FP CPA, IAC III III 4 No 40 40 5
12 FP TS II III 16 Yes 15 15 4
13 FPLS, GG III III 5 No 10 10 6
14 FP, V GG, MS III III 5 No 15 15 5
15 SNHL IAC I II 13 Yes 50 50 5
16 SNHL, FP IAC,GG III III 8 Yes 45 55 8
17 FP TS,MS II IV 12 Yes 15 40 7
18 FP, T TS, MS IIq II 3 No 15 15 9
19 SNHL, V CPA I III 15 Yes 50 50 9
20 FP GG II II 4 No 10 10 8
21 FP GG,TS,MS II IV 15 Yes 10 40 7

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 23, 2017 | Posted by in OTOLARYNGOLOGY | Comments Off on Long-term outcomes of facial nerve schwannomas with favorable facial nerve function: tumor growth rate is correlated with initial tumor size

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access